代码之家  ›  专栏  ›  技术社区  ›  Quibblesome

什么更快,打开字符串或Elseif打开类型?

performance c#
  •  72
  • Quibblesome  · 技术社区  · 17 年前

    假设我可以选择识别代码路径,以便根据字符串比较或其他类型进行区分:

    哪个更快,为什么? 

    switch(childNode.Name)
{
    case "Bob":
      break;
    case "Jill":
      break;
    case "Marko":
      break;
}

if(childNode is Bob)
{
}
elseif(childNode is Jill)
{
}
else if(childNode is Marko)
{
}

    更新: 我之所以问这个问题,主要是因为switch语句是Perculiar关于什么才算是一个案例。例如,它不允许您使用变量,只允许将常量移动到主程序集。我认为这是因为它所做的一些奇怪的事情。如果它只是翻译成elseifs(正如一个海报所评论的那样),那么为什么在case语句中不允许变量?

    Caveat: 我正在进行后期优化。此方法被调用 许多的 在应用程序的慢速部分的时间。

    23 回复  |  直到 17 年前
        1
  •  121
  •   Mani Gandham    8 年前 

    int value = 25124;
if(value == 0) ...
else if (value == 1) ...
else if (value == 2) ...
...
else if (value == 25124) ... 


    switch(value) {
 case 0:...break;
 case 1:...break;
 case 2:...break;
 ...
 case 25124:...break;
}


    switch(someString) {
    case "Foo": DoFoo(); break;
    case "Bar": DoBar(); break;
    default: DoOther; break;
}


    if(someString == "Foo") {
    DoFoo();
} else if(someString == "Bar") {
    DoBar();
} else {
    DoOther();
}

    Dictionary<string, int> 

    //Make sure the dictionary is loaded
if(theDictionary == null) { 
    //This is simplified for clarity, the actual implementation is more complex 
    // in order to ensure thread safety
    theDictionary = new Dictionary<string,int>();
    theDictionary["Foo"] = 0;
    theDictionary["Bar"] = 1;
}

int switchIndex;
if(theDictionary.TryGetValue(someString, out switchIndex)) {
    switch(switchIndex) {
    case 0: DoFoo(); break;
    case 1: DoBar(); break;
    }
} else {
    DoOther();
}


    private delegate void NodeHandler(ChildNode node);

static Dictionary<RuntimeTypeHandle, NodeHandler> TypeHandleSwitcher = CreateSwitcher();

private static Dictionary<RuntimeTypeHandle, NodeHandler> CreateSwitcher()
{
    var ret = new Dictionary<RuntimeTypeHandle, NodeHandler>();

    ret[typeof(Bob).TypeHandle] = HandleBob;
    ret[typeof(Jill).TypeHandle] = HandleJill;
    ret[typeof(Marko).TypeHandle] = HandleMarko;

    return ret;
}

void HandleChildNode(ChildNode node)
{
    NodeHandler handler;
    if (TaskHandleSwitcher.TryGetValue(Type.GetRuntimeType(node), out handler))
    {
        handler(node);
    }
    else
    {
        //Unexpected type...
    }
}


    Testing 3 iterations with 5,000,000 data elements (mode=Random) and 5 types
Method                Time    % of optimal
If/Else               179.67  100.00
TypeHandleDictionary  321.33  178.85
TypeDictionary        377.67  210.20
Switch                492.67  274.21

Testing 3 iterations with 5,000,000 data elements (mode=Random) and 10 types
Method                Time    % of optimal
If/Else               271.33  100.00
TypeHandleDictionary  312.00  114.99
TypeDictionary        374.33  137.96
Switch                490.33  180.71

Testing 3 iterations with 5,000,000 data elements (mode=Random) and 15 types
Method                Time    % of optimal
TypeHandleDictionary  312.00  100.00
If/Else               369.00  118.27
TypeDictionary        371.67  119.12
Switch                491.67  157.59

Testing 3 iterations with 5,000,000 data elements (mode=Random) and 20 types
Method                Time    % of optimal
TypeHandleDictionary  335.33  100.00
TypeDictionary        373.00  111.23
If/Else               462.67  137.97
Switch                490.33  146.22

Testing 3 iterations with 5,000,000 data elements (mode=Random) and 25 types
Method                Time    % of optimal
TypeHandleDictionary  319.33  100.00
TypeDictionary        371.00  116.18
Switch                483.00  151.25
If/Else               562.00  175.99

Testing 3 iterations with 5,000,000 data elements (mode=Random) and 50 types
Method                Time      % of optimal
TypeHandleDictionary  319.67    100.00
TypeDictionary        376.67    117.83
Switch                453.33    141.81
If/Else               1,032.67  323.04



    Testing 3 iterations with 5,000,000 data elements (mode=UniformFirst) and 50 types
Method                Time    % of optimal
If/Else               39.00   100.00
TypeHandleDictionary  317.33  813.68
TypeDictionary        396.00  1,015.38
Switch                403.00  1,033.33


    Testing 3 iterations with 5,000,000 data elements (mode=UniformLast) and 50 types
Method                Time      % of optimal
TypeHandleDictionary  317.67    100.00
Switch                354.33    111.54
TypeDictionary        377.67    118.89
If/Else               1,907.67  600.52

        2
  •  18
  •   Greg    17 年前 


    class Program
{
    static void Main( string[] args )
    {
        Bob bob = new Bob();
        Jill jill = new Jill();
        Marko marko = new Marko();

        for( int i = 0; i < 1000000; i++ )
        {
            Test( bob );
            Test( jill );
            Test( marko );
        }
    }

    public static void Test( ChildNode childNode )
    {   
        TestSwitch( childNode );
        TestIfElse( childNode );
    }

    private static void TestIfElse( ChildNode childNode )
    {
        if( childNode is Bob ){}
        else if( childNode is Jill ){}
        else if( childNode is Marko ){}
    }

    private static void TestSwitch( ChildNode childNode )
    {
        switch( childNode.Name )
        {
            case "Bob":
                break;
            case "Jill":
                break;
            case "Marko":
                break;
        }
    }
}

class ChildNode { public string Name { get; set; } }

class Bob : ChildNode { public Bob(){ this.Name = "Bob"; }}

class Jill : ChildNode{public Jill(){this.Name = "Jill";}}

class Marko : ChildNode{public Marko(){this.Name = "Marko";}}
        3
  •  17
  •   ilitirit    17 年前 

    class Node
{
    public virtual void Action()
    {
        // Perform default action
    }
}

class Bob : Node
{
    public override void Action()
    {
        // Perform action for Bill
    }
}

class Jill : Node
{
    public override void Action()
    {
        // Perform action for Jill
    }
}

        4
  •  12
  •   Nescio    17 年前

        5
  •  6
  •   Gary Kephart    17 年前

        6
  •  4
  •   Rick Minerich    17 年前

        7
  •  3
  •   Chris Upchurch    17 年前

        8
  •  3
  •   user17983    17 年前

        9
  •  3
  •   Ted Elliott    17 年前 

    Dictionary<Type, HandlerDelegate> handlers = new Dictionary<Type, HandlerDelegate>();
handlers[typeof(Bob)] = this.HandleBob;
handlers[typeof(Jill)] = this.HandleJill;
handlers[typeof(Marko)] = this.HandleMarko;

handlers[childNode.GetType()](childNode);
/// ...

private void HandleBob(Node childNode) {
    // code to handle Bob
}
        10
  •  2
  •   moonshadow    17 年前

        11
  •  2
  •   Community CDub    8 年前

    http://www.blackwasp.co.uk/SpeedTestIfElseSwitch.aspx

    What is quicker, switch on string or elseif on type?

        12
  •  2
  •   SaguiItay    17 年前 

    switch(childNode.Name)
{
    case "Bob":
        break;
    case "Jill":
        break;
    case "Marko":
      break;
}

if(childNode.Name == "Bob")
{}
else if(childNode.Name == "Jill")
{}
else if(childNode.Name == "Marko")
{}
        13
  •  2
  •   nawfal Donny V.    12 年前 

    interface INode
{
    void Action;
}

class Bob : INode
{
    public void Action
    {

    }
}

class Jill : INode
{
    public void Action
    {

    }
}

class Marko : INode
{
    public void Action
    {

    }
}

//Your function:
void Do(INode childNode)
{
    childNode.Action();
}


    enum NodeType { Bob, Jill, Marko, Default }

interface INode
{
    NodeType Node { get; };
}

class Bob : INode
{
    public NodeType Node { get { return NodeType.Bob; } }
}

class Jill : INode
{
    public NodeType Node { get { return NodeType.Jill; } }
}

class Marko : INode
{
    public NodeType Node { get { return NodeType.Marko; } }
}

//Your function:
void Do(INode childNode)
{
    switch(childNode.Node)
    {
        case Bob:
          break;
        case Jill:
          break;
        case Marko:
          break;
        Default:
          throw new ArgumentException();
    }
}

    if nanoseconds does matter for you

        14
  •  2
  •   Walter Verhoeven    7 年前

    Core 2 console app with output 

      public static class StringExtention
    {
        public static long ToUniqueHash(this string text)
        {
            long value = 0;
            var array = text.ToCharArray();
            unchecked
            {
                for (int i = 0; i < array.Length; i++)
                {
                    value = (value * 397) ^ array[i].GetHashCode();
                    value = (value * 397) ^ i;
                }
                return value;
            }
        }
    }

    public class AccountTypes
    {

        static void Main()
        {
            var sb = new StringBuilder();

            sb.AppendLine($"const long ACCOUNT_TYPE = {"AccountType".ToUniqueHash()};");
            sb.AppendLine($"const long NET_LIQUIDATION = {"NetLiquidation".ToUniqueHash()};");
            sb.AppendLine($"const long TOTAL_CASH_VALUE = {"TotalCashValue".ToUniqueHash()};");
            sb.AppendLine($"const long SETTLED_CASH = {"SettledCash".ToUniqueHash()};");
            sb.AppendLine($"const long ACCRUED_CASH = {"AccruedCash".ToUniqueHash()};");
            sb.AppendLine($"const long BUYING_POWER = {"BuyingPower".ToUniqueHash()};");
            sb.AppendLine($"const long EQUITY_WITH_LOAN_VALUE = {"EquityWithLoanValue".ToUniqueHash()};");
            sb.AppendLine($"const long PREVIOUS_EQUITY_WITH_LOAN_VALUE = {"PreviousEquityWithLoanValue".ToUniqueHash()};");
            sb.AppendLine($"const long GROSS_POSITION_VALUE ={ "GrossPositionValue".ToUniqueHash()};");
            sb.AppendLine($"const long REQT_EQUITY = {"ReqTEquity".ToUniqueHash()};");
            sb.AppendLine($"const long REQT_MARGIN = {"ReqTMargin".ToUniqueHash()};");
            sb.AppendLine($"const long SPECIAL_MEMORANDUM_ACCOUNT = {"SMA".ToUniqueHash()};");
            sb.AppendLine($"const long INIT_MARGIN_REQ = { "InitMarginReq".ToUniqueHash()};");
            sb.AppendLine($"const long MAINT_MARGIN_REQ = {"MaintMarginReq".ToUniqueHash()};");
            sb.AppendLine($"const long AVAILABLE_FUNDS = {"AvailableFunds".ToUniqueHash()};");
            sb.AppendLine($"const long EXCESS_LIQUIDITY = {"ExcessLiquidity".ToUniqueHash()};");
            sb.AppendLine($"const long CUSHION = {"Cushion".ToUniqueHash()};");
            sb.AppendLine($"const long FULL_INIT_MARGIN_REQ = {"FullInitMarginReq".ToUniqueHash()};");
            sb.AppendLine($"const long FULL_MAINTMARGIN_REQ ={ "FullMaintMarginReq".ToUniqueHash()};");
            sb.AppendLine($"const long FULL_AVAILABLE_FUNDS = {"FullAvailableFunds".ToUniqueHash()};");
            sb.AppendLine($"const long FULL_EXCESS_LIQUIDITY ={ "FullExcessLiquidity".ToUniqueHash()};");
            sb.AppendLine($"const long LOOK_AHEAD_INIT_MARGIN_REQ = {"LookAheadInitMarginReq".ToUniqueHash()};");
            sb.AppendLine($"const long LOOK_AHEAD_MAINT_MARGIN_REQ = {"LookAheadMaintMarginReq".ToUniqueHash()};");
            sb.AppendLine($"const long LOOK_AHEAD_AVAILABLE_FUNDS = {"LookAheadAvailableFunds".ToUniqueHash()};");
            sb.AppendLine($"const long LOOK_AHEAD_EXCESS_LIQUIDITY = {"LookAheadExcessLiquidity".ToUniqueHash()};");
            sb.AppendLine($"const long HIGHEST_SEVERITY = {"HighestSeverity".ToUniqueHash()};");
            sb.AppendLine($"const long DAY_TRADES_REMAINING = {"DayTradesRemaining".ToUniqueHash()};");
            sb.AppendLine($"const long LEVERAGE = {"Leverage".ToUniqueHash()};");
            Console.WriteLine(sb.ToString());

            Test();    
        }    

        public static void Test()
        {
            //generated constant values
            const long ACCOUNT_TYPE = -3012481629590703298;
            const long NET_LIQUIDATION = 5886477638280951639;
            const long TOTAL_CASH_VALUE = 2715174589598334721;
            const long SETTLED_CASH = 9013818865418133625;
            const long ACCRUED_CASH = -1095823472425902515;
            const long BUYING_POWER = -4447052054809609098;
            const long EQUITY_WITH_LOAN_VALUE = -4088154623329785565;
            const long PREVIOUS_EQUITY_WITH_LOAN_VALUE = 6224054330592996694;
            const long GROSS_POSITION_VALUE = -7316842993788269735;
            const long REQT_EQUITY = -7457439202928979430;
            const long REQT_MARGIN = -7525806483981945115;
            const long SPECIAL_MEMORANDUM_ACCOUNT = -1696406879233404584;
            const long INIT_MARGIN_REQ = 4495254338330797326;
            const long MAINT_MARGIN_REQ = 3923858659879350034;
            const long AVAILABLE_FUNDS = 2736927433442081110;
            const long EXCESS_LIQUIDITY = 5975045739561521360;
            const long CUSHION = 5079153439662500166;
            const long FULL_INIT_MARGIN_REQ = -6446443340724968443;
            const long FULL_MAINTMARGIN_REQ = -8084126626285123011;
            const long FULL_AVAILABLE_FUNDS = 1594040062751632873;
            const long FULL_EXCESS_LIQUIDITY = -2360941491690082189;
            const long LOOK_AHEAD_INIT_MARGIN_REQ = 5230305572167766821;
            const long LOOK_AHEAD_MAINT_MARGIN_REQ = 4895875570930256738;
            const long LOOK_AHEAD_AVAILABLE_FUNDS = -7687608210548571554;
            const long LOOK_AHEAD_EXCESS_LIQUIDITY = -4299898188451362207;
            const long HIGHEST_SEVERITY = 5831097798646393988;
            const long DAY_TRADES_REMAINING = 3899479916235857560;
            const long LEVERAGE = 1018053116254258495;

            bool found = false;
            var sValues = new string[] {
              "AccountType"
              ,"NetLiquidation"
              ,"TotalCashValue"
              ,"SettledCash"
              ,"AccruedCash"
              ,"BuyingPower"
              ,"EquityWithLoanValue"
              ,"PreviousEquityWithLoanValue"
              ,"GrossPositionValue"
              ,"ReqTEquity"
              ,"ReqTMargin"
              ,"SMA"
              ,"InitMarginReq"
              ,"MaintMarginReq"
              ,"AvailableFunds"
              ,"ExcessLiquidity"
              ,"Cushion"
              ,"FullInitMarginReq"
              ,"FullMaintMarginReq"
              ,"FullAvailableFunds"
              ,"FullExcessLiquidity"
              ,"LookAheadInitMarginReq"
              ,"LookAheadMaintMarginReq"
              ,"LookAheadAvailableFunds"
              ,"LookAheadExcessLiquidity"
              ,"HighestSeverity"
              ,"DayTradesRemaining"
              ,"Leverage"
            };

            long t1, t2;
            var sw = System.Diagnostics.Stopwatch.StartNew();
            foreach (var name in sValues)
            {
                switch (name)
                {
                    case "AccountType": found = true; break;
                    case "NetLiquidation": found = true; break;
                    case "TotalCashValue": found = true; break;
                    case "SettledCash": found = true; break;
                    case "AccruedCash": found = true; break;
                    case "BuyingPower": found = true; break;
                    case "EquityWithLoanValue": found = true; break;
                    case "PreviousEquityWithLoanValue": found = true; break;
                    case "GrossPositionValue": found = true; break;
                    case "ReqTEquity": found = true; break;
                    case "ReqTMargin": found = true; break;
                    case "SMA": found = true; break;
                    case "InitMarginReq": found = true; break;
                    case "MaintMarginReq": found = true; break;
                    case "AvailableFunds": found = true; break;
                    case "ExcessLiquidity": found = true; break;
                    case "Cushion": found = true; break;
                    case "FullInitMarginReq": found = true; break;
                    case "FullMaintMarginReq": found = true; break;
                    case "FullAvailableFunds": found = true; break;
                    case "FullExcessLiquidity": found = true; break;
                    case "LookAheadInitMarginReq": found = true; break;
                    case "LookAheadMaintMarginReq": found = true; break;
                    case "LookAheadAvailableFunds": found = true; break;
                    case "LookAheadExcessLiquidity": found = true; break;
                    case "HighestSeverity": found = true; break;
                    case "DayTradesRemaining": found = true; break;
                    case "Leverage": found = true; break;
                    default: found = false; break;
                }

                if (!found)
                    throw new NotImplementedException();
            }
            t1 = sw.ElapsedTicks;
            sw.Restart();
            foreach (var name in sValues)
            {
                switch (name.ToUniqueHash())
                {
                    case ACCOUNT_TYPE:
                        found = true;
                        break;
                    case NET_LIQUIDATION:
                        found = true;
                        break;
                    case TOTAL_CASH_VALUE:
                        found = true;
                        break;
                    case SETTLED_CASH:
                        found = true;
                        break;
                    case ACCRUED_CASH:
                        found = true;
                        break;
                    case BUYING_POWER:
                        found = true;
                        break;
                    case EQUITY_WITH_LOAN_VALUE:
                        found = true;
                        break;
                    case PREVIOUS_EQUITY_WITH_LOAN_VALUE:
                        found = true;
                        break;
                    case GROSS_POSITION_VALUE:
                        found = true;
                        break;
                    case REQT_EQUITY:
                        found = true;
                        break;
                    case REQT_MARGIN:
                        found = true;
                        break;
                    case SPECIAL_MEMORANDUM_ACCOUNT:
                        found = true;
                        break;
                    case INIT_MARGIN_REQ:
                        found = true;
                        break;
                    case MAINT_MARGIN_REQ:
                        found = true;
                        break;
                    case AVAILABLE_FUNDS:
                        found = true;
                        break;
                    case EXCESS_LIQUIDITY:
                        found = true;
                        break;
                    case CUSHION:
                        found = true;
                        break;
                    case FULL_INIT_MARGIN_REQ:
                        found = true;
                        break;
                    case FULL_MAINTMARGIN_REQ:
                        found = true;
                        break;
                    case FULL_AVAILABLE_FUNDS:
                        found = true;
                        break;
                    case FULL_EXCESS_LIQUIDITY:
                        found = true;
                        break;
                    case LOOK_AHEAD_INIT_MARGIN_REQ:
                        found = true;
                        break;
                    case LOOK_AHEAD_MAINT_MARGIN_REQ:
                        found = true;
                        break;
                    case LOOK_AHEAD_AVAILABLE_FUNDS:
                        found = true;
                        break;
                    case LOOK_AHEAD_EXCESS_LIQUIDITY:
                        found = true;
                        break;
                    case HIGHEST_SEVERITY:
                        found = true;
                        break;
                    case DAY_TRADES_REMAINING:
                        found = true;
                        break;
                    case LEVERAGE:
                        found = true;
                        break;
                    default:
                        found = false;
                        break;
                }

                if (!found)
                    throw new NotImplementedException();
            }
            t2 = sw.ElapsedTicks;
            sw.Stop();
            Console.WriteLine($"String switch:{t1:N0} long switch:{t2:N0}");
            var faster = (t1 > t2) ? "Slower" : "faster";
            Console.WriteLine($"String switch: is {faster} than long switch: by {Math.Abs(t1-t2)} Ticks");
            Console.ReadLine();

        }
        15
  •  0
  •   Magsol    17 年前

        16
  •  0
  •   JeeBee    17 年前

        17
  •  0
  •   Mark Bessey    17 年前

        18
  •  0
  •   Joe    17 年前

    http://msdn.microsoft.com/en-us/library/f7dy01k1(VS.80).aspx

    http://msdn.microsoft.com/en-us/library/aa309387(VS.71).aspx

        19
  •  0
  •   Eddie Velasquez    17 年前

    dotTrace

        20
  •  0
  •   nimish    17 年前

        21
  •  0
  •   Walter Verhoeven    7 年前 

    //somewhere in your code
static long _bob = "Bob".GetUniqueHashCode();
static long _jill = "Jill".GetUniqueHashCode();
static long _marko = "Marko".GeUniquetHashCode();

void MyMethod()
{
   ...
   if(childNode.Tag==0)
      childNode.Tag= childNode.Name.GetUniquetHashCode()

   switch(childNode.Tag)
   {
       case _bob :
        break;
       case _jill :
         break;
       case _marko :
        break;
   }
}


    public static class StringExtentions
    {
        /// <summary>
        /// Return unique Int64 value for input string
        /// </summary>
        /// <param name="strText"></param>
        /// <returns></returns>
        public static Int64 GetUniquetHashCode(this string strText)
        {
            Int64 hashCode = 0;
            if (!string.IsNullOrEmpty(strText))
            {
                //Unicode Encode Covering all character-set
                byte[] byteContents = Encoding.Unicode.GetBytes(strText);
                System.Security.Cryptography.SHA256 hash =  new System.Security.Cryptography.SHA256CryptoServiceProvider();
                byte[] hashText = hash.ComputeHash(byteContents);
                //32Byte hashText separate
                //hashCodeStart = 0~7  8Byte
                //hashCodeMedium = 8~23  8Byte
                //hashCodeEnd = 24~31  8Byte
                //and Fold
                Int64 hashCodeStart = BitConverter.ToInt64(hashText, 0);
                Int64 hashCodeMedium = BitConverter.ToInt64(hashText, 8);
                Int64 hashCodeEnd = BitConverter.ToInt64(hashText, 24);
                hashCode = hashCodeStart ^ hashCodeMedium ^ hashCodeEnd;
            }
            return (hashCode);
        }


    }

    here

        22
  •  0
  •   Thrawn Wannabe    7 年前

    this benchmark test switch if-else ?

    that post if-else-if-else

        23
  •  -1
  •   Aeon    17 年前 

    switch(childNode.Type)
{
case Bob:
  break;
case Jill:
  break;
case Marko:
  break;
}
    推荐文章
    Sweepy Dodo  ·  JSON lite的格式化
    7 月前
    Merlin Nestler  ·  为什么索引中的列顺序在这种情况下会产生如此大的影响?
    8 月前
    giantjenga  ·  优化整数向量到二进制向量的转换
    9 月前
    Adriaantje  ·  Powershell版本的cut-d在处理大文件时速度很慢,我是否错过了快速的方法?
    9 月前
    Costinean Sebastian  ·  如何优化使用for循环处理大型数组的MATLAB脚本的执行时间?"
    9 月前
    Zegarek  ·  Postgresql递归查询未提供预期结果
    9 月前
    Joe  ·  为什么这两个查询之间的性能存在如此大的差异?
    1 年前
    tic-toc-choc  ·  在`dplyr中高效使用列表进行过滤`
    1 年前
    Mohan  ·  是否有一种更快的方法来编写代码,从1:N中提取许多随机样本?
    1 年前
    user2980746  ·  在C#字典中键入xyz对的最有效方法是什么?
    1 年前
    关于   移动版
    代码之家 - 一站式码农服务社区
    沪ICP备11025650号